http://www.familysecuritymatters.org/publications/detail/true-caring-compassion-and-social-justice
THIS IS NICE AND DANDY….BUT I AM ALSO A FORMERLY “LIBERAL” DEMOCRAT….AND CARING, COMPASSION AND SOCIAL JUSTICE HAVE TAKEN A BACK BURNER TO SURVIVAL AS A JEW, AS AN AMERICAN, AS A DEFENDER OF ISRAEL….THE REST IS FEEL GOOD STUFF IN THE FACE OF BLATANT ANTI-AMERICAN, ANTI-SEMITIC, ANTI ISRAEL LIBELS….READ ROGER SIMONS COLUM “HOW DO YOU SLEEP’….THAT’S MORE LIKE IT…RSK
A former Democratic Jew reflects on our politics of caring and compassion.
I’m part of a minority within a minority: a Jewish Republican who volunteers for the Jewish Republican Coalition and Republican Party. I know Jews take pride in being socially conscious and compassionate. However, I also know there is a tension in the American Jewish world over defining these virtues.
Now that the Holiday and election seasons are upon us, moral and intellectual clarity is demanded.
My experience suggests that most Jews today see “caring” through a lens far astray from a Biblical one. It’s called Progressive, Leftist or Liberal.
The minority, including myself and many traditional Orthodox Jews, believe this viewpoint is not the true Jewish or American perspective. We believe conservative Republican values and policies actually express the true definition of caring and compassion, especially on two central topics of this year’s elections: abortion, and the size and role of government.
The typical response I receive from typical liberal Jews is that , “Conservatives are terrible on social issues. They have a war on women. They support government invasion into women’s bodies and elimination of woman’s right to control her reproductive freedom.”
It’s a classic straw-man argument, mixed with distortion and untruth, but it effectively guides Jewish votes to liberal Democrat candidates, election after election, as though abortion were the only social issue and this deliberately narrow interpretation the only valid viewpoint.
The irony is that the conservative philosophy actually holds the most nuanced, just, Jewish and traditional American views on this social justice topic. This philosophy says abortion cannot be merely some binary pronouncement on a “right to choose or not.” The issue is far more complex, involving life and death, the nature of our moral compass. It is deeply connected to our traditional Biblical and American belief that all people are created in the image of God. It demands a profound consideration of the developing human.
Most fundamentally, it is not simply a woman’s “right” to decide to eradicate a developing human baby – especially if it is merely for convenience. Society, our moral character, potential adopting parents, the child’s father, grandparents, sisters and brothers, all have claims and interests that must be carefully regarded.
The Liberal turns the mother alone into the final arbiter, the philosopher, policeman, lawyer, judge, jury and death administrator regarding this human life. The Liberal approach is also illogical, producing a viewpoint that at one moment a human inside a woman’s uterus has only the worth of a tooth abscess to be shed, often at whim; but a moment later, outside the uterus, that same life is of infinite God-level worth.
But that is where the argument tends to end with the Jewish Democrat. The conservative is seen as regressive on abortion, and abortion is by definition “social issues.” That is incorrect.
The size and scope of government, and its proper role in our lives and economic system are likewise vital to our society – central “social issues.” Abortion affects each of us rarely, while these other social issues profoundly impact our daily lives.
THIS IS NICE AND DANDY….BUT I AM ALSO A FORMERLY “LIBERAL” DEMOCRAT….AND CARING, COMPASSION AND SOCIAL JUSTICE HAVE TAKEN A BACK BURNER TO SURVIVAL AS A JEW, AS AN AMERICAN, AS A DEFENDER OF ISRAEL….THE REST IS FEEL GOOD STUFF IN THE FACE OF BLATANT ANTI-AMERICAN, ANTI-SEMITIC, ANTI ISRAEL LIBELS…..RSK
A former Democratic Jew reflects on our politics of caring and compassion.
I’m part of a minority within a minority: a Jewish Republican who volunteers for the Jewish Republican Coalition and Republican Party. I know Jews take pride in being socially conscious and compassionate. However, I also know there is a tension in the American Jewish world over defining these virtues.
Now that the Holiday and election seasons are upon us, moral and intellectual clarity is demanded.
My experience suggests that most Jews today see “caring” through a lens far astray from a Biblical one. It’s called Progressive, Leftist or Liberal.
The minority, including myself and many traditional Orthodox Jews, believe this viewpoint is not the true Jewish or American perspective. We believe conservative Republican values and policies actually express the true definition of caring and compassion, especially on two central topics of this year’s elections: abortion, and the size and role of government.
The typical response I receive from typical liberal Jews is that , “Conservatives are terrible on social issues. They have a war on women. They support government invasion into women’s bodies and elimination of woman’s right to control her reproductive freedom.”
It’s a classic straw-man argument, mixed with distortion and untruth, but it effectively guides Jewish votes to liberal Democrat candidates, election after election, as though abortion were the only social issue and this deliberately narrow interpretation the only valid viewpoint.