A few days ago, the executive director of Human Rights Watch, Kenneth
Roth,tweeted the following statement: “Germans rally against
anti-Semitism that flared in Europe in response to Israel’s conduct in
Gaza war. Merkel joins.” Roth provided a link to a New York Times
article about the rally, which took place in Berlin.
Roth’s framing of this issue is very odd and obtuse. Anti-Semitism in
Europe did not flare “in response to Israel’s conduct in Gaza,” or
anywhere else. Anti-Semitic violence and invective are not responses
to events in the Middle East, just as anti-Semitism does not erupt
“in response” to the policies of banks owned by Jews, or in response
to editorial positions taken by The New York Times. This is for the
simple reason that Jews do not cause anti-Semitism.
It is a universal and immutable rule that the targets of prejudice are
not the cause of prejudice. Just as Jews (or Jewish organizations, or
the Jewish state) do not cause anti-Semitism to flare, or intensify,
or even to exist, neither do black people cause racism, nor gay people
homophobia, nor Muslims Islamophobia. Like all prejudices,
anti-Semitism is not a rational response to observable events; it is a
manifestation of irrational hatred. Its proponents justify their
anti-Semitism by pointing to the (putatively offensive or repulsive)
behavior of their targets, but this does not mean that major figures
in the world of human-rights advocacy should accept these pathetic
excuses as legitimate.