Bring Them Home, Mr. President Iran learned from the first hostage crisis how to make U.S. prisoners pay off.By William McGurn
http://www.wsj.com/articles/bring-them-home-mr-president-1451345958
On Thursday night as the ball drops in Times Square, millions of Americans watching on TV will join the revelers in Manhattan to celebrate the new year. For other Americans, alas, the arrival of Jan. 1 will mark only the beginning of another year behind Iranian bars.
It’s long past time to bring these men home.
At last year’s White House welcome for Bowe Bergdahl—the soldier who walked away from his combat post in Afghanistan and will soon be tried for desertion and misbehavior before the enemy—President Obama did manage to refer to other Americans “unjustly detained abroad” who also “deserve to be reunited with their families.”
“There was not a meeting that took place, not one meeting that took place—believe me, that’s not an exaggeration—where we did not raise the issue of our American citizens being held.”
Mr. Kerry is oblivious to the obvious: If what he says is true, it only confirms his impotence.
Back when the nukes deal was being negotiated, the idea was that an agreement would clear the way for these Americans to be freed. That hasn’t happened, and it hasn’t happened because the Iranians are not stupid. As Commentary’s Jonathan Tobin noted recently, “Each American prisoner makes Iran that much more confident that nothing it does will tempt Obama to stop the deal.”
This helps explain why Iran in October convicted a Washington Post reporter of bogus espionage charges, after the deal was reached. Indeed, that same month Iran arrested an Iranian-American businessman named Siamak Namazi.
The reporter’s name is Jason Rezaian, and he has been held captive for more than 500 days since his arrest. A year ago, Mr. Kerry released a statement saying he was “personally dismayed and disturbed” by the charges against Mr. Rezaian. Unfortunately, Mr. Kerry’s personal dismay hasn’t disturbed the Iranians.
Robert Levinson is another story. The former FBI agent disappeared in Iran in 2007 while on a half-baked CIA mission. The Iranians say they don’t know what happened to Mr. Levinson, the father of seven. At one point he was written off as dead, until photos surfaced showing him alive. And now Mr. Kerry expects a regime that won’t come clean about Mr. Levinson to be forthcoming about its nuclear program?
Amir Hekmati is an American-born Marine veteran arrested in Iran in 2011 while visiting his grandmother. He has kept up the fight from prison, at one point smuggling out a letter in which he said that a televised confession he’d made had been done under duress—and asked Mr. Kerry to reject any overture from Tehran to trade him for Iranian operatives held in the U.S.
Saeed Abedini is another detained Iranian-American and a convert to Christianity. Though Iran claims to respect the right of Christian worship, Christians are harassed and Mr. Abedini was arrested when he returned to Iran to build an orphanage. Such are the menaces to Iran these days. He has been in jail since 2012.
It’s important to repeat these names—loudly, frequently and in public. The reason is that such Americans have no natural constituency pleading for them, outside of their families and the occasional congressman. For a White House, there’s always some trade deal, some military exercise or other agreement that can make the plight of an individual American seem less a call for action than an irritant to the diplomatic agenda.
While we’re on the subject of Americans unjustly locked up abroad, Pakistan continues to hold the doctor who helped us get Osama bin Laden. Dr. Shakil Afridi is not a U.S. citizen. But how can we expect people to help us if we leave them to the wolves when they do? Dr. Afridi’s incarceration is a testament to both Pakistan’s bad faith and President Obama’s bad policies.
Every one of these lives is important, not least to the families who pray for the safe release of their loved ones. But their cases hold a larger importance too. Because the world becomes a much more dangerous place when the message goes out that it’s open season on Americans.
The only real protection for our vulnerable citizens abroad is this: The certainty among bad guys that they will pay a swift and severe price for molesting an American citizen.
In the first Iranian hostage crisis, Jimmy Carter at least made Iran pay by banning Iranian imports and freezing its assets. In this new hostage crisis, by contrast, the Americans held prisoner are paying off for Iran, not only by making it harder for Mr. Obama to punish any Iranian cheating on the nuclear deal but in the regime’s access to tens of billions in unfrozen assets.
Why should Iran change a winning hand?
Comments are closed.
