If there’s one lesson to be learned on the 10th anniversary of the Second Lebanon War, it is that brokered cease-fires and U.N. resolutions are not to be trusted in the Middle East, where the definitions of “victory” and “defeat” are elusive.
For 34 days during the summer of 2006, Hezbollah pummeled the Jewish state with rockets, and the Israel Defense Forces conducted airstrikes to destroy the infrastructure and weaponry of the bloodthirsty Shiite organization, which — in typical Arab terrorist fashion — were strategically placed in and around the homes and schools of civilians.
When the war was over, both sides declared victory, though then-Prime Minister Ehud Olmert’s announcement sounded feeble to most Israelis. The regular IDF soldiers and reservists who participated in the fighting felt particularly deflated and bitter. When the war was over, their stories of inadequate equipment and lack of training for the missions they were sent to conduct emerged to everyone’s horror and disgust. One friend of mine recounted having to improvise all the time — for example, by using chocolate spread as face camouflage, and operating a tank with which he was completely unfamiliar.
The Winograd Commission, set up in the aftermath of the war, delved into these and other mishaps on the leadership and military levels. But the real culprit was a false assessment, reached more than a decade earlier, that the “conventional battlefield” was a thing of the past. According to this ridiculous theory, it would be wasteful to expend energy and resources training for ground incursions, when the era of high-tech sorties from the air was the wave of the future.
Still, analysts pointed to the major blow suffered by Hezbollah in the war, pointing to the “restoration of quiet” in the north and the heavy losses incurred by the terrorist group. One such optimist was Iranian-born, London-based Middle East expert Amir Taheri, who visited the Jewish state in May 2007, less than a year after the war was over — on the eve of the release of the Winograd Commission’s interim findings.