https://quadrant.org.au/opinion/america/2024/03/shredding-the-law-to-get-donald-trump/
Nothing has shocked me as much recently as the result of New York Attorney-General Letitia James’ prosecution of Donald Trump, following closely, as it did, on the absurd award of $83 million in damages for defamation to memory-challenged alleged sexual assault victim, E. Jean Carroll.
If you’re not reporting for the mainstream media, you know this is a politically motivated hit-job. In other words, an attack on the very essence of American democracy. You know, the ultimate sin of which Trump stands accused. The one for which he must be defeated later this year. James told us exactly that when she campaigned for election on a platform of getting Trump:
I will never be afraid to challenge this illegitimate president,” James said in a video during the campaign. “I believe that this president is incompetent. I believe that this president is ill-equipped to serve in the highest office of this land. And I believe that he is an embarrassment to all that we stand for.” She went on to say Trump should be indicted on criminal charges and charged with obstruction of justice.
So, even before she had any case, she was determined to pursue him, not because of any crime she may have suspected he committed but because in her eyes he was both an illegitimate president and incompetent. But, no doubt under the influence of Trump Derangement Syndrome, James would have been confident a fishing expedition would yield some dirt.
There are many troubling aspects to this case. The first is the staggering amount of the fine – US464 million. And the second is that this matter was prosecuted as a civil fraud case.
New York, which reputedly has some of the toughest fraud legislation in the country, recognises two types of fraud – civil and criminal. Here, from the website of East Coast Laws, is a short summary:
Fraud can be both a civil and criminal offense in New York. Civil fraud involves a breach of contract or a violation of a legal duty, resulting in harm to another party. The victim of civil fraud can sue the perpetrator and seek damages in court. Criminal fraud, on the other hand, involves intentionally deceiving someone for personal gain, which is a violation of the law. Criminal fraud is prosecuted by the government, and the penalties can include fines, imprisonment, and other criminal sanctions.