https://www.spiked-online.com/2025/03/19/israel-has-every-right-to-eliminate-hamas/
Andrew Fox is a former British Army officer and an associate fellow at the Henry Jackson Society, specialising in defence and the Middle East.
The ceasefire in Gaza collapsed this week. IDF airstrikes have now resumed, targeting infrastructure and taking out senior Hamas officials. Israel has also issued an evacuation order for the entire Gaza border area, likely signalling a renewed ground invasion. When I was speaking with Israeli insiders in Jerusalem a few weeks ago, it was suggested to me that five entire divisions may be deployed. A deployment of this scale would likely mean the seizure of all of Gaza by the IDF.
The breakdown of the ceasefire in Gaza was predictable, inevitable and solely the responsibility of Hamas. Rather than acting as a genuine partner in peace, it has become evident that Hamas used the ceasefire as a tactical pause to regroup, rearm and prepare for the next wave of violence. Israel – confronted with Hamas’s failure to negotiate in good faith for the release of hostages and phase two of the ceasefire – is entirely justified in resuming efforts to dismantle Hamas as a military threat once and for all.
US president Donald Trump’s insistence on a ceasefire in Gaza posed significant challenges for Israel. When it was agreed in January, the job was only half complete. Hamas continued to hold power and hostages remained trapped in Gaza. However, after weeks of negotiations, one positive outcome of this enforced pause has been the reuniting of many hostages with their families.
The ceasefire has also exposed the truly monstrous nature of Hamas. The dire condition of the returned hostages – as well as the grotesque spectacle of hostage releases, in which the coffins of innocents were paraded before crowds and cameras – served as a stark reminder of Hamas’s barbarism. Meanwhile, seeing Israel return well-fed Gazans has dispelled notions of genocide or deliberate starvation for any sane observer.
Since then, phase two of the ceasefire talks has failed (despite the White House negotiating directly with Hamas, over Israel’s head). Hamas cocked a snook at both the Israelis and the White House, having been warned by Trump what would happen if it continued to stall on releasing the remaining hostages. Now, Trump has given the Israelis the green light to resume targeting senior Hamas members.
Trump’s ceasefire was never likely to be more than a temporary reprieve for Hamas. After all, the group remains fundamentally committed to the destruction of Israel – an aim baked into its founding charter. Any agreement with an organisation whose raison d’être is conflict can only ever be short-lived. Since 7 October 2023, when Hamas launched its unprecedented massacre against civilians in southern Israel, the terror group has repeatedly demonstrated that it does not recognise peace. Rather, it uses pauses in fighting to regain strength.