RUTHFULLY YOURS

In Moscow, meanwhile, Colonel Oleg Konstantinovich Penkovsky (above) of the GRU (Glavnoye Razvedyvatel’noe Upravlenie, Chief Intelligence Directorate of Military Intelligence) was arrested and  charged with the high treason. The world was not to know at the time that it was Penkovsky, much more than Khrushchev, Kennedy or their diplomats, who defused the crisis. The Soviets would slink home with tails and rockets between their legs and, two years later, the Politburo “relieved”  Khrushchev of the leadership position. These were the unfolding consequence of Penkovsky’s actions, yet the man who saved the planet by supplying the Americans with top secret information that gave Washington the confidence to resist the Kremlin’s bluff and bluster has remained a largely obscure and overlooked player in the drama.

Penkovsky’s part was scripted by his superior,  the four-star General Ivan Alexandrovich Serov. According to a January, 1998, account in Red Star, the official newspaper of the Russian Federation’s armed forces, he ordered his subordinate to “infiltrate an American and the British intelligence network in Moscow in order to win their trust.” The theory is that Serov prompted Penkovski to supply Washington with the data that revealed the USSR’s nuclear arsenal was nowhere near as ominous as Western intelligence agencies had been led to believe, lacking both missile numbers, range and deliverable throw weight.

Serov died in 1990 in comfort and  prosperity. He was not prosecuted for his war crimes, nor was he charged with any of his other offences against humanity — the looting, for example, of conquered nations’ treasures and mass deportations of Chechens, Balts and Tartars. Nor was he called to account for his wholesale slaughter of Ukrainian nationalists and Polish prisoners of war.

There are other players, too, whose names need to be recalled, amongst them Chief Marshal of Artillery and Rocket  Forces, Sergey Sergeevich, who was demoted in the wake of the Cuba crisis to the rank of one-star general. Penkovsky had been Varentzov’s combat comrade during WWII and appears to have used this friendship to access secret documents detailing the locations of the Soviet’s nuclear arsenal, the invaluable backgrounding that was passed to the Americans. Accused of “loss of political vigilance”, Sergeevich was stripped of almost all privileges but never formally charged with treason.

Finally, there is Marshal Sergei Semenovich Biryuzov, chairman of the Soviet General  Staff and the boss of both Varentsov and Serov, who is suspected of initiating the unprecedented transfer of that top-secret information as part of the conspiracy to frustrate the Khrushchev’s madcap schemes and provocations. Intriguingly, he would die in a suspicious plane crash the day after Khrushchev’s ouster in October, 1964.

All these years later, two fundamental questions remained unanswered:

• Why did Khrushchev put those rockets in Cuba in the first place, knowing full well that he could not match America’s nuclear muscle?
• After learning of the mortal threat in Cuba, just 90 miles from Florida, why did Kennedy ignore military advice and decline to launch a pre-emptive strike?

Before we attempt to work through the through the muddle of intrigue, let’s establish some facts.

• Despite impressive achievements in the early days of what came to be known as the Space Race, the USSR did not have the capacity to strike the continental US with nuclear-tipped rockets: there were just five — repeat, five! — intercontinental ballistic missiles available to be launched. Their locations were surrounded by easily identifiable infrastructure, oxygen plants and similar, and vulnerable to US strikes. None of these missiles was in a state of combat readiness, nor had they ever been. In other words, the USSR was able to strike Europe, but not the US.
• Khrushchev installed in Cuba 154 nuclear warheads which, in theory, could strike the US without warning. The reality was rather different. Each rocket required an extended period of pre-launch preparation, during which every one was vulnerable.
• Kennedy was  alerted to this Soviet threat by the intelligence and the operating manuals supplied by Penkovsky. The US President  was  thus gifted with priceless inside view of the  details of the procedures and preparation required  for the launch of each of the missile types. He clearly understood that he could destroy these missiles and, further, that he had the luxury of  time to formulate a response to Russian aggression.
• Because such intelligence was available to him via Penkovsky’s leaks, Kennedy did not strike the Soviet weaponry in Cuba.  He also resisted military advisors’ urging that he knock out those well known nuclear sites inside of the USSR.
• As Kennedy was blessed to know, the Soviet threats were hollow. When that bluff was called, Khrushchev’s public humiliation and the removal of nuclear weaponry from Cuban became inevitable.

That the world survived without being dotted by mushroom clouds is, ultimately, the work of one man, Oleg Vladimirovich Penkovsky. Some call him traitor, others a hero. But, like Claus von Stauffenberg, he was certainly a martyr to his beliefs. Like von Stauffenberg, he shared the same fate: executed in short order after his arrest.

None of the above even begins to explain why Khrushchev precipitated the Cuba Crisis in the first place. To find that answer we must look beyond Moscow, Washington and the Caribbean to Europe, most particularly Berlin. The Soviet-controlled eastern half of that divided city was losing one person per minute as residents voted with their feet and decamped to the West. Before the infamous wall went up, fleeing communism was a simple and largely risk-free matter of crossing a line drawn only on maps. East Germany was emptying, losing the most productive strata of its population. The Soviets understood the danger went further than the loss of their captive nation’s best and brightest. As long as East Germans were able to compare at close quarters the functioning of the two systems, the entire Soviet chimera was in danger of evaporating. After all, if many Germans wanted no truck with an alleged workers’ paradise, why shouldn’t Poles and Czechs follow their example?

Grasping the danger of this simple, potentially lethal truth, Khrushchev understood he had to get the Western Allies out of Berlin — indeed, from all of Western Germany — if the Soviet Empire were to survive. His whole idea for promoting a crisis in the Caribbean arose from the hope that Washington and the West would find it expedient to make a trade: Russia would erase the threat it had installed in Cuba if the West were to remove a threat of another kind from Germany. In pursuit of this gambit, he used Soviet space achievements to foster the entirely false belief that he had at his disposal an unlimited supply of intercontinental missiles capable of striking the US.

At the end of the day, Khrushchev did not realise that threats without the substance could easily have prompted a very substantive reaction, as advocated by bomber general Curtis Le May and others.

Hero or villain, Penkovsky averted a global catastrophe and paid dearly for his bravery. For that the modern world remains deeply in his debt.

A timeline of the Caribbean crisis and the Soviet space achievements

• 21^st August, 1957    –    first successful launch of the Soviet intercontinental missile/rocket,  8K-71.
• 4^th October, 1957   – the same rocket delivered the first man made Earth satellite on the orbit.
• 3rd November, 1957 – first living creature (a dog named Laika, meaning the Barker)  in space.
• In a short period of time there were pennants with the Soviet coat of arms, delivered on the Moon surface, the flight around the moon.
• 17^th December, 1957 – creation of the Strategic Rocket Forces of the Soviet Union.
• 12^th April, 1958  – First man in space!
• 27^th November, 1958 – Berlin ultimatum – Get out of Berlin, you, imperialist warmongers, you!
• 20^th April, 1958 –Penkovsky’s first contact with the British intelligence service.
• 6-7^th August, 1961 – Second man in space, 17 orbital turns.
• 9^th August, 1961 – Khrushchev threatens the world with the nuclear charge of more than 100 megatons.
• 12-13^th August, 1961 –  Berlin wall erection.
• 26^th October, 1961 – Berlin crisis
• 30thOctober 1961 – nuclear test of the charge with the explosive power equivalent of  57millions tones. The Hiroshima bomb was 20 kilotons.
• 24^th May 1962 – Defence Ministry presents the Presidium of the Central Committee of the CPSU (The then name of the Politburo) plan under the code name  Anadyr, detailing an establishment of a nuclear attack force on Cuba directed against the mainland USA. The plan called for the location of the 51^st rocket division with its intermediary range (up to 2200km) weaponised nuclear warheads, together with the delivery means and an anti aircraft defence in Cuban territory with the clearly stated aim of threatening the USA. This plan was implemented under the strictest secrecy provisions and required 21thousand goods carriages, 86 cargo vessels, which had to conduct 180 return journeys from the Soviet ports to Cuban ones.
• 4^th October 1962 – The Soviet SS Indigarka  delivers nuclear warheads for the  8-K63 intermediate range missile to the Cuban port Mariel.
• 14^th October 1962 – Americans discover these weapons, demand these weapons to be removed.  He Soviets ignore these messages, then try to reassure Americans that they are mistaken.
• 22^nd October 1962 – US President gives the speech to the nation. The naval blockade of Cuba is declared and enforced.
• 23^rd October 1962 – Khrushchev was fuming in his letter, accusing Americans of piracy, aggression and warmongering, threatening to give a “fitting response” to an “American provocation”.
• 24^th October – The 20 Soviet ships on the way to Cuba turn back.
• 25^th October 1962 – Adlay Stevenson delivers the devastating  rebuke to the Soviets during the UN Security Council emergency meeting, demonstrating the photo evidence to the whole world to see.
• 26^th October 1962– Khrushchev backs down and sends a telegram to Kennedy in which he agrees to remove Russian rockets from Cuba, provided the USA lifts the blockade and promise not to invade the island.
• 27^th October 1962 – Khrushchev sends a letter, in which he demands the removal of the US missiles from Turkey. The US U2 plane is shot down over Cuba. The situation is becoming critical, despite the Khrushchev’s letter. Kennedy in under enormous pressure to launch a preventive strike.  He refuses.
• 28^th October 1962 – Kennedy ignores the follow up letter from Khrushchev as well as a shooting down of the U2 plane. He writes Nikita Khrushchev that the US will not invade Cuba and will lift the blockade if the USSR will dismantle the nuclear bases. Secretly, he promises to dismantle the US missile bases  in Turkey.
• Had Penkovski not supplied Americans with the data, incontrovertibly (and verifyingly!) proving that the Soviet threat is a bluff, Kennedy would have had no choice but to launch the first strike. The crisis was over. The world had survived.

 Dr Michael Galak and his family came to Australia as refugees from the Soviet Union in 1978

Supporting quotations and their sources.

Why did the Soviet Union put missiles in Cuba?

“The Soviet Union put missiles in Cuba for two primary reasons: (1) to boost the Soviet Union’s power, threatening the U.S. with nuclear attack from the Caribbean and (2) to bolster the Soviet Union’s bargaining position in its attempts to force West Berlin to join East Germany. Additional reasons included defending Cuba from American invasion and bolstering Soviet prestige.”

Harvard Kennedy School.

Belfer Centre for Science and International Affairs. Cuban missile crisis.

Did the Soviets put their nuclear warheads on Cuban soil before the blockade declaration ?

“At the time, the CIA reported that they did not believe the nuclear warheads for the missiles had been delivered to Cuba. As I recall, they believed that the first shipment of warheads was aboard the ship Poltava, a ship which was to arrive in Cuba within a few days.”

However, the CIA assessment was wrong and the US Government knew it.  As the quote from the presentation  by Robert Macnamara  in his own words  at the Havana conference in 1992 demonstrates,  the US Government was  painfully aware of the existence of the Soviet nuclear warheads already on the Cuban soil before the blockade imposition, all 162 of them.

“These events seemed dangerous at the time. But it wasn’t until nearly thirty years afterward that we learned, from General Gribkov’s testimony at a January 1992 conference here in this room in Havana, that the nuclear warheads for both tactical and strategic nuclear weapons had already reached Cuba before the quarantine line was established—162 nuclear warheads in all. If the president had gone ahead with the air strike and invasion of Cuba, the invasion forces almost surely would have been met by nuclear fire, requiring a nuclear response from the United States.”

Arms control association web site. Transcript of Robert Maknamara’s presentation at the Conference on Cuban missile crisis. Havana, January 1992.

Was the intelligence supplied by Oleg Penkovsky of such significance that it allowed US President to resist the pressure to launch the first strike?

“The intelligence supplied by Penkovsky – almost 5,500 exposures on a Minox camera over a period of eighteen months- was of the highest importance. It included up-to-date surveys of Soviet intercontinental ballistic missiles (several thousand fewer than US estimates), the alert stages, checks and firing sequence of the Soviet Strategic Rocket Forces, statistics on missile accuracy and defects revealed in test firing. Penkovsky’s  revelations about increased Soviet reliance on missile and a vast chemical warfare programme led to a major rethink in NATO strategy. At peak periods  , the intelligence provided by Penkovsky, who was run jointly  by  SIS and the CIA , kept busy twenty American and ten British analysts.

Good intelligence in the West  was crucial to the peaceful resolution of the Cuban missile crisis before the missiles themselves had been installed.

On 14^th of October 1962 a U2 over Cuba  took the first photographs of a ballistic missile site under construction. CIA analysts were able to identify the nature of the sites  because of a top-secret document detailing the stages in missile site construction secretly photographed by Penkovsky… On  16 October the photographs were placed before the President.”

Christopher Andrew, Oleg Gordievsky: “KGB:THE INSIDE STORY” pp.389, 390.