https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/12/18/irelands-anti-israel-stance-is-embarrassingly-hypocritical/
Ireland and Israel are now locked in a zero-sum war of reputation destruction. On Sunday, Israel announced it was closing its Dublin embassy because of the “extreme anti-Israel policies of the Irish government”. It then doubled down, branding the Taoiseach, Simon Harris, an anti-Semite. An irate Harris shot back that Israel was merely attempting to distract from its “killing” of children.
These accusations are so grave it’s difficult to see how either side can walk them back. Who, after all, would make such claims frivolously?
Let’s consider for a moment what led both countries to go nuclear. Since the start of the war in Gaza, the Irish government has been one of Israel’s most strident critics. It backed South Africa’s genocide case against Israel in the International Court of Justice (ICJ), claiming there was sufficient evidence to answer the charge. But just last week, it went further, calling to “broaden” the definition of genocide to vaguely include civilian harm, effectively turning Israel into a perpetrator of a crime yet to exist.
For Jerusalem, this attempt to shift legal goalposts, redefining established terms to engineer guilt, was the final straw. After years of diplomatic snubs, boycotts, and genocide accusations – not to mention Ireland’s recognition of a Palestinian state soon after October 7 – Israel decided to cut its losses. “We will now channel and transfer resources to a place that is interested in cooperating with us,” its ambassador explained.
The Taoiseach, for his part, called the decision regrettable but dismissed accusations of Irish hostility toward Israel. “We’re just pro-peace, pro-human rights, and pro-international law,” he protested. But Ireland’s record speaks louder than platitudes.
Ireland is for international law when it suits. That’s why it now seeks to rewrite the Genocide Convention – an international cornerstone ratified by 153 states, including Ireland – to retroactively lower the bar for convicting Israel. This more closely resembles authoritarian justice, where the accused is condemned first and the crime tailored to fit. As Stalin’s secret police chief Lavrentiy Beria put it: “Show me the man, and I’ll show you the crime.”