ON THE ISSUES….WHO WON?

Posted By on October 17th, 2012

http://ace.mu.nu/archives/333917.php

October 17, 2012

CBS Poll: Romney Wins 65-34 on Economy;

CNN Poll: Romney Wins 54-40 on Economy,
49-46 on Health Care,
51-44 on Taxes,
59-36 on Deficit,
49-46 on Leadership,
All in Favor of Romney

You now, as far as “Debate Winner” it’s pretty close with those registered voters. CBS gives it to Obama, among registered voters 37-30. CNN’s registered voters gives it to Obama 46-39.

But on actual issues — the ones that will determine this election — Romney destroyed him.

CNN’s focus group claimed they thought Obama “won.” They had it something like 14 for Obama, 15 draw, 6 Romney.

But even that group said this– on the question of “Who offers a better vision for the future?,” Romney edged Obama 18-17.

Now that’s very slim. I wouldn’t read too much into that.

But consider: More people think Romney presents a better vision for the future — the quickest possible shorthand for “who should be President?” — and yet he didn’t “win” the debate?

You always have to question what the criteria people are employing when you ask them who “won.” I think people are rating the performance. And narrowly saying, on performance, it was a close thing, but edge to Obama.

But ask about who actually reached them on the most important issues, and it’s Romney, all the way.

So they seem to be distinguishing between performance and substance.

Romney wins the substance, pretty clearly.

I’ll take it. And give Obama his charity performance points.
More: Foreign policy, Obama edges 49-47.

But this is amazing: Did Obama offer a clear vision for solving the country’s problems?

38% Yes

61% No

61% No. Wow.

How about that asked about Romney?

49% Yes

50% No

A Specatator Culture: Americans have gotten pretty sophisticated about judging performance, especially after 10 years of American Idol.

We shouldn’t assume that when people answer the question “Who won the debate?” they confuse that question with “Who did you find more persuasive?”

They might actually be offering a sophisticated analysis: “I think this guy won on debate performance points.”

But then ask them “Who actually persuaded you?,” and they might answer a completely different way.

It certainly appears that’s what happened here tonight.

More: NumbersMuncher has even more of the below-the-topline polling questions.

Romney wins.

Categorized under: ANTI-SEMITISM.
Tagged with: no tags.

Comments are closed.