Outrage in France after civil servants were paid to do nothing for 25 years by David Chazan
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2019/06/30/outrage-france-revealed-city-toulon-paid-civil-servants-do-nothing/
A regional authority in the south of France paid some 30 civil servants to do nothing for more than 25 years, it has been revealed.
French taxpayers have been spending more than €1 million (£897,000) a year to pay full salaries to the “phantom” bureaucrats, despite at least one of them being in full-time private sector employment.
An official report by the Provence-Alps-Riviera Regional Audit Office disclosed that others benefited from automatic promotions and pay increases based on seniority or length of service.
The report said local authorities had failed to find them posts after their original jobs were scrapped when water services were privatised in the southern city of Toulon – but kept them on the payroll.
“It is regrettable, to say the least, that the city was not capable of finding new jobs for some of these employees, especially the youngest,” the audit office report said.
French private-sector workers often despair at the “jobs for life” culture of the country’s bloated civil service and public sector, which employs nearly 20 per cent of the country’s workforce.
But the existence of so many “phantom fonctionnaires” has shocked the nation at a time when French workers feel overburdened by what many see as excessive taxes and the high cost of living.
The audit office report was revealed by Var Matin, a local newspaper, only two months after an economy ministry report revealed that more than 300,000 civil servants fail to fulfil their obligation to work 35 hours a week.
France’s statutory working week is one of the shortest in the world, but many private-sector workers say they put in extra hours to achieve their targets. President Emmanuel Macron has promised to shed 120,000 civil service jobs as part of a drive to cut €60 billion (nearly £54 billion) in public spending by 2022.
One of the 30 “fonctionnaires” paid for doing nothing, an administrative assistant, took a private-sector job as a manager during eight years when he continued to receive his civil service salary.
The audit office report noted that the Var management centre responsible for the non-existent civil servants “had little motivation to find them new jobs” because as long as it reported a deficit, the bulk of their salaries would continue to be paid out of the budgets of the local authorities that had originally employed them.
“The budget forecast of the Management Centre is presented showing a deficit each year to trigger a specific legal provision allowing continued funding of the remuneration of staff without jobs,” the report said.
The audit office also criticised the “jobless” civil servants for maximising their pensions by remaining on the payroll until reaching the working age limit of 67.
It is not the first case of public-sector employees being paid for doing nothing in France. In 2016, a senior civil servant was found to have claimed his monthly salary of nearly €4,000 (£3,588 at the current exchange rate) for 10 years without doing a day’s work.
Another case concerned the state rail company, SNCF, which paid a manager more than €5,000 (£4,485) a month for 12 years although he was not working.
In 2016, a Spanish court fined a civil servant who had collected full pay for 14 years without going to his office.
Perhaps more surprisingly, uber-efficient Germany was embarrassed by the revelation in 2012 that a civil servant had been paid for 14 years without doing any work. At the time, Germany was leading calls for public-sector austerity cuts in eurozone countries such as Greece and Spain.
Comments are closed.
