“Something is Rotten in the State of Denmark” Sydney Williams
http://www.swtotd.blogspot.com
When Marcellus utters Shakespeare’s immortal line, he speaks of the corruption that led to Hamlet’s father, King Hamlet, being murdered. When Mr. Gingrich wrote the words in the rubric, it reflected his opinion that corruption, incompetence and dishonesty have come to characterize American politics. One does not have to be in accord with all that Mr. Gingrich believes to agree that politics in the United States has become polarized and that people, in general, have become disenchanted with those who labor in the vineyards along the Potomac.
Complaints about politics and political leaders are as old as civilization, but they have reached new heights in the U.S., and, in fact, in much of the West. A PEW Research study, conducted a year ago, concluded: “Just 4% of U.S. adults say the political system is working extremely or very well; another 23% say it is working somewhat well.” Things have worsened since. On August 21 of this year Statista Research put the approval rating for the U.S. Congress at 16 percent. Keep in mind, this is despite the 118th Congress “being the most diverse Congress in American history.” Their report concluded that “nearly 60% of Americans have no confidence the parties can govern in a bipartisan way.”
When asked how they feel when they think of politics in the PEW study, 65% said they were “always/often exhausted”. Asked as to what words best described the current state of American politics, “divisive” and “corrupt” were the top choices. Members of Congress, especially those on the left, are famous for extolling wealth and income disparities. Yet, the median net worth of an individual member of Congress is more than five times the median net worth of American households. Wikipedia, in a list of presidents ranked by net worth, adjusted for inflation to 2022 U.S. dollars, shows that three of the last five U.S. Presidents head the list: Donald Trump, Barack Obama and Bill Clinton. (George W. Bush is twelfth and Joe Biden is tied with Eisenhower for twenty-second.) Last on the list is Harry Truman, who famously replied when offered a corporate board seat: “You don’t want me; you want the U.S. Presidency, and it’s not for sale.” Today, everything in politics is for sale, including access.
“Antiestablishment populism is on the rise in Europe, fueled not just by migration and economic and security fears, but also by a deeper trend: eroding confidence in governments’ ability to overcome these challenges;” so began an article in last Tuesdays The Wall Street Journal by Bertrand Benoit. This lack of confidence in government can be seen in recent elections in Italy, the UK, Germany, the Netherlands, and France. As for problems of inflation, migration and the war in Ukraine, there is, as Mr. Benoit wrote, “confidence is crumbling that elected governments can solve them.”
In the U.S., our history has become a cesspool of political correctness. Schools and colleges depict our forefathers as racists and colonizers who despoiled an idyllic Eden. Certainly, we should not revere the Founders of our nation as God-like figures, but we should acknowledge that slave holders like Washington, Jefferson, Madison and Monroe bequeathed us a government that gave us, over time, Lincoln and the Emancipation Proclamation, and then, a hundred years further on, Civil Rights. Is all perfect today? No. We should always strive to improve, but we should never lose sight of the fact that it has been our history of free speech, free enterprise and limited government that have been foundational to our culture and economic growth, the latter which has provided us with living standards unimaginable to our grandparents, even to our parents.
Without a common enemy to hate, such as Nazi Germany or the Soviet Union, we have lost our moral compass. The substitution of climate change as an “existential threat,” while popular among Western elitists, does not work. It is an excuse to justify more government control. The Earth’s climate has changed continuously over its billions of years of existence, long before man made his appearance. It will continue to change. Like all living things, man must adapt. It is true that man has used many of the Earth’s resources to improve his living standards, which certainly has had some effect on climate. But, as aspiration, ability, diligence, and free markets made him wealthier and gave him more leisure time, he became more conscious of his environment. When an individual is battling for subsistence he cares not what happens to his waste. The best way to improve the environment in the undeveloped world is to promote economic growth.
The absence of morality is deadly. It can be seen in the attitude of Western politicians who apply a moral equivalence toward the democratic nation of Israel and the terrorist organization Hamas, which governs (or did govern) Gaza. When six hostages were recently shot execution-style by Hamas terrorists, the reaction by the White House (and most leaders in Europe) was to blame Israel along with Hamas, but specifically Israel Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu for failing to achieve a cease fire. Why have we lost our sense of right and wrong? The West is challenged in many places. Leaders of China want hegemony in the Pacific, Russia’s Putin wants to restore his country’s Soviet empire, and Iran would like to dominate the Middle East. America’s role should be that “shining city on the hill,” a phrase first used by Jesus in his Sermon on the Mount, then by John Winthrop in 1630, and 259 years later by Ronald Reagan – an example of what man is capable.
I am not so cynical as to believe that someone, or some group, is deliberately trying to undermine our nation and its values – family, work, accountability and responsibility, courage, respect for others, individualism and unity, fairness, merit, care for those less fortunate – though it sometimes seems that way. What I do know is that something is wrong in our country, and in the West – it is the fissures that divide us; it is the sense of entitlement that permeates our bureaucracy and some of our people; it is the claim that exceptional achievements of thousands of individual Americans over hundreds of years was only possible because of a benevolent state. Newt Gingrich is right. Our politics is undergoing a profound (and disheartening) change. We should never be blind to our faults. We should always strive to improve our lot and that of those around us. But we should celebrate our successes, and we should learn from our failures.
At its essence, the United States has been a virtuous country, as has been the West. Both provided individuals the freedom to succeed based on merit, which, in turn, has raised living standards for their citizens, and both have given promise of opportunities to millions who live elsewhere, those whose lives have been reduced by dictators and barbarians. Both have defended freedom. But when nations ignore the moral compass that allowed them to succeed, when they denigrate their history and disregard their Judeo-Christian heritage, they offer an opening to authoritarians, whether from the right or the left. That is what is rotten, and that is the risk the U.S. and the West face.
Comments are closed.
