https://melaniephillips.substack.com/p/epidemic-of-illogicality?token=
One of the many regrettable consequences of the Covid-19 crisis has been an epidemic of illogicality. Thus:
Countries which originally locked down have rising infection rates. Therefore lockdown was useless and the economic damage it caused was entirely unnecessary.
Sweden never locked down and now its infection rate is negligible. Therefore we should all have behaved like Sweden.
Although infection rates are rising, the numbers who are dying or need intensive care have declined. Therefore the crisis is over and there’s no need for any more restrictions.
Most of the rising infection rates involve young people. Young people don’t generally have a serious form of the virus. Therefore the crisis is over and there’s no need for any more restrictions.
A lot of the statistics being banded about are rubbish. This proves the whole idea that this pandemic requires drastic action is rubbish.
Despite the panic having been unjustified hysteria from the start, government ministers are still deliberately ramping up public terror in order to increase the power of the state and seize control of our lives.
Duh?
Such arguments, and many more in similar vein, display a regrettable failure to acknowledge complexity, or the difference between correlation and causation, or the concept of being between a rock and a hard place – which means the alternative to something bad may not be something good but something else that’s bad too. Does that really need spelling out? Apparently so.